Quantitative Study of Straw Bio-oil Hydrodeoxygenation over a Sulfided NiMo Catalyst

Scientific articles | 2019 | REFINE LabInstrumentation
GC/MSD, HPLC, GC
Industries
Energy & Chemicals
Manufacturer
Thermo Fisher Scientific

Importance of the topic


The hydrotreatment (hydrodeoxygenation, HDO) of fast-pyrolysis bio-oil is a key pathway to convert lignocellulosic biomass into refinery-compatible liquid fuels and intermediates. Detailed, molecule-level quantification of how individual oxygenates react during HDO is essential to optimize catalysts, minimize hydrogen consumption, and improve product stability and compatibility with petroleum streams.

Objectives and overview of the study


This study provides a quantitative mapping of how volatile and nonvolatile oxygenated molecules in straw-derived ablative fast-pyrolysis bio-oil are transformed during one-stage HDO over a sulfided NiMo/Al2O3 catalyst. Experiments covered a broad range of temperatures and hydrogen pressures to (i) quantify hundreds of species by GC-MS (directly and by surrogate), (ii) measure bulk functional-group loads by CAN (carboxylic acids), Faix (carbonyls), and Folin−Ciocalteu (phenolics), and (iii) derive relative reactivities of major oxygenate classes and recommend favorable operating conditions balancing deoxygenation and aromatic preservation.

Methodology


  • Feedstock: Straw bio-oil (wheat/barley 1:1) from ablative fast pyrolysis (550 °C, residence time <1 s) supplied by Fraunhofer UMSICHT; bio-oil separated into organic and aqueous phases after condensation.
  • Hydrotreatment: Continuous fixed-bed reactor with sulfided commercial NiMo/Al2O3 catalyst (expressed oxide loadings ~5.5 wt % NiO, 28.3 wt % MoO3). Two experiment series: T/4 (temperature sweep 240→350 °C at 4 MPa) and T/P (temperature 300–360 °C at pressures 2–8 MPa). WHSV = 1 h−1, H2 flow ≈ 90 L·h−1 at standard conditions. Feed doped with 0.5 wt % dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) to maintain sulfided state.
  • Quantitative chemical analysis: GC-MS with extensive standard mixtures for direct quantification of 115 compounds and indirect quantification (surrogate-based) of ~140 additional compounds. Complementary bulk assays applied to organic phases: CAN (potentiometric titration) for carboxylic acids, Faix potentiometric oximation-titration for carbonyls, and Folin−Ciocalteu spectrophotometric assay for phenols. Analyses performed in triplicate where applicable.

Used instrumentation


  • GC-MS: Thermo Focus GC with DSQ quadrupole MS, ZB-5MSi column (30 m + 5 m guard), EI 70 eV, full-scan 20–500 Da; injection 1 µL split 1:20; solvent acetone or n-butanol depending on analyte volatility. Two internal standards used (1-butoxypropan-2-ol and 2-naphthaldehyde) to cover early and late eluting regions.
  • CAN titration: Metrohm 716 DMS Titrino potentiometric titrator with tetrabutylammonium hydroxide titrant.
  • Faix carbonyl assay: Oximation in DMSO / ethanol and back titration (hydroxylamine hydrochloride then TEA), with titrimetric endpoints.
  • Folin−Ciocalteu total phenols: UV-1800 spectrophotometer (Shimadzu) at 765 nm, gallic-acid calibration.

Main results and discussion


  • Scope of quantification: In the feed organic phase roughly 32 wt % of volatile oxygenates were identified and quantified by GC-MS; for the most deoxygenated product (360 °C, 8 MPa) >50 wt % of volatile fraction was quantified. Overall GC-MS-accounted organic mass in products ranged ca. 23–38 wt % depending on conditions; adding water gave larger fractions quantified (e.g., ~48 wt % for feed).
  • Phase partitioning: Hydrotreated oil separated into organic and aqueous phases. Low-molecular oxygenates (acids, low alcohols, ketones) partitioned strongly into the aqueous phase—acetic acid was dominant (≥40% of aqueous organics). Several species (e.g., pyrocatechol, acetic acid) would appear “consumed” if only the organic phase were analyzed; thus both phases must be quantified.
  • Reactivity order of oxygenate classes (apparent, under WHSV = 1 h−1 over sulfided NiMo): aldehydes (fastest) → furanics / small oxygenates → ketones/alcohols (moderate) → esters/lactones → carboxylic acids (slow) → phenolics/monohydroxybenzenes (slowest). This ordering is consistent with complete disappearance of aldehydes at the mildest tested conditions and much higher resistance of phenolics and some sterically hindered alkylphenols.
  • Pyrolytic lignin decomposition: Increasing severity (temperature and pressure/time-on-stream) led to decomposition of pyrolytic lignin fragments and the formation of alkylated phenolics (especially propyl-substituted monocyclic phenols). Some propyl-phenolics increased in concentration even as other oxygenates declined, indicating lignin-derived feed components and secondary formation pathways.
  • Aromatic saturation vs deoxygenation: Hydrogenation (saturation) of aromatic rings began at higher severity; significant ring saturation was observed by 320 °C and 8 MPa. A balance of high deoxygenation while limiting aromatic hydrogenation was achieved at ~340 °C and 4 MPa—identified by the authors as the preferred one-stage condition for minimizing H2 consumption while obtaining a stable, refinery-compatible intermediate.
  • Hydrocarbon formation: n-Alkanes (odd carbon predominance for key C15–C17 fractions) were produced via decarbonylation/decarboxylation of fatty acids and ketones; maximum n-alkane yields observed around 340 °C and 8 MPa. However only a portion of acids/ketones converted to these n-alkanes, implicating additional sources (longer-chain cracking or higher-molecular precursors) and incomplete conversion pathways.
  • Functional-group bulk assays: CAN, Faix, and Folin−Ciocalteu provided complementary insight. Faix showed a sharp decrease in carbonyls (aldehydes and other carbonyl-rich high-MW species) between feed and mild products, indicating many carbonyls exist in higher-MW pyrolytic lignin fractions. CAN (carboxylic acids) indicated residual acidity in many products and demonstrated that a large share of volatile acids were captured by the aqueous phase; complete removal of GC-detectable acids occurred only under severe conditions (≥340 °C, 8 MPa). Folin−Ciocalteu trends were modest because assay response depends on hydroxyl substitution pattern and alkylation; it is useful as an antioxidant-capacity indicator rather than an absolute count of monomeric phenols.

Benefits and practical applications of the method


  • The multi-tiered analytical approach (extensive compound-specific GC-MS quantification together with functional-group titrations/assays) yields a detailed, quantitative map of reaction pathways during HDO of real pyrolysis bio-oil. This information supports rational catalyst design and process optimization to (i) improve removal of problematic functionalities (acids, carbonyls) and (ii) limit excessive hydrogenation of aromatics to save H2 cost and preserve desired fuel properties.
  • Identification of an operational sweet spot (≈340 °C, 4 MPa, WHSV 1 h−1 under tested conditions) provides a pragmatic target for one-stage upgrading intended to deliver refinery-coprocessable intermediates with reasonable hydrogen consumption.
  • Quantitative partitioning data and phase-specific speciation enable improved mass balances, better estimation of aqueous effluent treatment needs, and more accurate hydrogen-demand calculations for scale-up.

Future trends and opportunities


  • Catalyst optimization: Improve sulfided catalyst formulations (active metal ratios, promoters, supports) to increase selectivity for carboxylic-acid removal and reduce coke/deactivation while maintaining low aromatic hydrogenation.
  • Multi-stage and integrated processing: Combine mild front-end HDO (to stabilize and remove highly reactive oxygenates) with subsequent selective upgrading steps (hydrocracking, fractionation, targeted deoxygenation) for tailored fuel production with lower total H2 demand.
  • Analytical advances: Expand validated GC-MS libraries, improve quantification of high-boiling and coeluting species (e.g., by 2D-GC, high-resolution MS), and refine bulk functional assays to better deconvolute contributions of mono-, di-, and polyfunctional species.
  • Feedstock and process variability: Apply this quantitative mapping to other feedstocks and pyrolysis modes to build predictive models that link biomass composition, pyrolysis conditions, and HDO behavior—enabling feedstock-flexible upgrading strategies.

Conclusions


Comprehensive, compound-level quantification combined with functional-group assays provides a clear picture of transformation pathways in straw bio-oil HDO over a sulfided NiMo catalyst. Aldehydes and small oxygenates are removed readily, while carboxylic acids and monohydric phenols are far more resistant and govern product acidity and stability. A compromise operating window around 340 °C and 4 MPa delivers substantial deoxygenation with limited aromatic saturation, representing an attractive single-stage route to refinery-compatible intermediates. The presented dataset guides both catalyst development and process design seeking to minimize hydrogen consumption while maximizing product quality.

Reference


  1. Bridgwater, A. V. Review of fast pyrolysis of biomass and product upgrading. Biomass and Bioenergy 2012, 38, 68–94.
  2. Mohan, D.; Pittman, C. U.; Steele, P. H. Pyrolysis of wood/biomass for bio-oil: a critical review. Energy & Fuels 2006, 20, 848–889.
  3. Mortensen, P. M.; Grünwaldt, J. D.; Jensen, P. A.; Knudsen, K. G.; Jensen, A. D. A review of catalytic upgrading of bio-oil to engine fuels. Applied Catalysis A: General 2011, 407, 1–19.
  4. Bi, Y.; Wang, G.; Shi, Q.; Xu, C.; Gao, J. Compositional changes during hydrodeoxygenation of biomass pyrolysis oil. Energy & Fuels 2014, 28, 2571–2580.
  5. Staš, M.; Kubička, D.; Chudoba, J.; Pospı́šil, M. Overview of analytical methods used for chemical characterization of pyrolysis bio-oil. Energy & Fuels 2014, 28, 385–402.
  6. Elliott, D. C. Historical developments in hydroprocessing bio-oils. Energy & Fuels 2007, 21, 1792–1815.
  7. Zacher, A. H.; Olarte, M. V.; Santosa, D. M.; Elliott, D. C.; Jones, S. B. A review and perspective of recent bio-oil hydrotreating research. Green Chemistry 2014, 16, 491–515.
  8. Ferrell, J. R.; Olarte, M. V.; Christensen, E. D.; Padmaperuma, A. B.; Connatser, R. M.; Stankovikj, F.; Meier, D.; Paasikallio, V. Standardization of chemical analytical techniques for pyrolysis bio-oil: history, challenges, and current status of methods. Biofuels, Bioproducts & Biorefining 2016, 10, 496–507.
  9. Christensen, E.; Ferrell, J.; Olarte, M. V.; Padmaperuma, A. B. Acid Number Determination of Pyrolysis Bio-oils using Potentiometric Titration: Laboratory Analytical Procedure (LAP). National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), 2016.
  10. Black, S.; Ferrell, J.; Olarte, M. V.; Padmaperuma, A. B. Determination of Carbonyls in Pyrolysis Bio-oils by Potentiometric Titration. Faix Method. Laboratory Analytical Procedure (LAP). National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), 2016.
  11. Rover, M. R.; Brown, R. C. Quantification of total phenols in bio-oil using the Folin−Ciocalteu method. Journal of Analytical and Applied Pyrolysis 2013, 104, 366–371.
  12. Stankovikj, F.; McDonald, A. G.; Helms, G. L.; Garcia-Perez, M. Quantification of bio-oil functional groups and evidences of the presence of pyrolytic humins. Energy & Fuels 2016, 30, 6505–6524.
  13. Auersvald, M.; Shumeiko, B.; Staš, M.; Kubička, D.; Chudoba, J.; Šímaček, P. Quantitative study of straw bio-oil hydrodeoxygenation over a sulfided NiMo catalyst. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 2019, 7, 7080–7093.

Content was automatically generated from an orignal PDF document using AI and may contain inaccuracies.

Downloadable PDF for viewing
 

Similar PDF

Efficient One-Stage Bio-Oil Upgrading over Sulfided Catalysts
Bio-based refinery intermediate production via hydrodeoxygenation of fast pyrolysis bio-oil
Hydrotreatment of straw bio-oil from ablative fast pyrolysis to produce suitable refinery intermediates
Upgrading of hydrothermal liquefaction biocrudes from mono- and co-liquefaction of cow manure and wheat straw through hydrotreating and distillation