GC/MSD, Elemental Analysis, Titration
IndustriesEnergy & Chemicals
ManufacturerMetrohm, Agilent Technologies
Significance of the topic
The paper investigates upgrading of hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL) biocrudes produced from agricultural wet wastes (wheat straw, cow manure and an optimized co-liquefaction blend) to refinery-compatible hydrocarbons by catalytic hydrotreating and subsequent fractional distillation. Converting wet agricultural residues to liquid hydrocarbons avoids energy-intensive drying, increases circular carbon use and offers a pathway to reduce fossil fuel dependence for sectors that require liquid fuels (aviation, shipping, heavy transport). The study evaluates practical process parameters and product quality relevant for integration with existing refinery operations and waste valorization schemes.
Study objectives and overview
Main objectives:
- Assess effects of feedstock composition (wheat straw, cow manure, and co-HTL blend) on hydrotreating performance.
- Investigate influence of hydrotreating severity (NiMo reactor zone temperatures 340, 360, 380, 400 °C) under continuous flow conditions on yields and product quality.
- Distil the highest-severity hydrotreated oils and characterize distillate cuts (gasoline, kerosene, diesel, bottom residue) for potential fuel use and refinery co-processing.
- Establish carbon flows from biomass to upgraded liquids and identify bottlenecks (notably nitrogen-containing species).
Methodology and experimental design
Feedstock and HTL production:
- Three continuous HTL campaigns produced biocrudes from: wheat straw (straw), cow manure (manure) and an optimized manure:straw mixture (co-HTL).
- Biocrudes were solvent-filtered (acetone) and recovered; ≈2.5 kg of each biocrude used per hydrotreatment run.
Hydrotreating setup and operating conditions:
- Continuous down-flow packed-bed reactor with co-current hydrogen (99.9 %), operating pressure 80 bar and hydrogen flow 45 NL·h−1.
- Two-stage catalyst bed: CoMo (2.8 wt% Co, 10.3 wt% Mo on Al2O3, 35 g) upstream and NiMo (2.5 wt% Ni, 13.4 wt% Mo on Al2O3, 50 g) downstream; beds separated by glass beads to control temperature profile.
- Catalysts sulfided in situ (4.4 wt% dimethyl disulfide in hydrotreated gasoil) and stabilized prior to biocrude feed.
- Biocrude feed rate 25 g·h−1 (WHSV 0.7 h−1 on CoMo bed and 0.5 h−1 on NiMo bed), hydrogen-to-oil mass ratio ≈0.18.
- NiMo-zone target temperatures tested: 340, 360, 380, 400 °C. Sampling after stabilization (≥4 h); for the 400 °C case two aliquots (400I, 400II) were collected.
Product work-up and analyses:
- Liquid products separated into oil and aqueous phases (centrifugation used to ensure separation).
- Selected 400 °C oil phases (400I + 400II combined per feedstock) distilled using a spiral column into four cuts: gasoline <150 °C, kerosene 150–250 °C, diesel 250–360 °C, bottom residue (BR) >360 °C.
- Solubility (miscibility) tests of BR with vacuum gas oil (VGO) performed by microscopy.
Instrumentation used
Key analytical and process equipment used in the study included:
- Continuous HTL pilot plant (Aarhus University)
- Packed-bed hydrotreating reactor with controlled dual-bed heating
- CoMo and NiMo commercial sulfide catalysts (specifications above)
- Elemental combustion analyzer (Elementar Vario EL Cube) for C H N S
- Karl Fischer coulometric titration for water
- Anton Paar Stabinger SVM 3000 viscometer for density and viscosity
- Metrohm 888 Titrando for TAN and basic nitrogen (UOP 269-10)
- Conradson micro carbon residue (Normalab NMC 420)
- GC–MS (Agilent 7890B/5977A) for volatile/semivolatile composition
- Simulated distillation (Agilent 6890 with DB-HT SIMDIS column)
- Agilent 7200 QTOF GC–MS for saturates analysis; Agilent SPALTROHR HMS500 spiral column for distillation
Main results and discussion
Hydrotreatment yields and mass/carbon balances:
- Upgraded liquid (oil) mass yields ranged ≈65–85 wt% (biocrude basis); carbon yields to upgraded oil ≈75–85 wt% (biocrude basis).
- Single-feedstock biocrudes (straw or manure) recovered on average ≈81 wt% of carbon as upgraded oil across temperatures; co-HTL biocrude showed strong temperature dependence, dropping oil carbon recovery from 92 wt% at 340 °C to 73 wt% at 400 °C.
- Gaseous carbon yields increased with hydrotreatment severity (C2–C7 hydrocarbons dominated gas phase). Aqueous-phase carbon yields remained low (<1 wt%).
Nitrogen behavior and hydrogen consumption:
- Co-HTL biocrude contained more recalcitrant nitrogen-containing heteroaromatics (Maillard-derived N-heterocycles), which resisted hydrodenitrogenation and lowered hydrogen consumption (co-HTL H2 consumption 11–18 gH2·kg−1 oil DB vs 18–36 gH2·kg−1 for single biocrudes).
- Denitrogenation improved with temperature for single-feedstock biocrudes (<50 % of initial N remained at higher temperatures), whereas co-HTL retained a larger fraction of nitrogen in the oil over the tested range (less pronounced N removal).
- Fraction of basic N increased after mild hydrotreating (low-temperature products) and decreased with higher severity; co-HTL products maintained higher basic-N fractions, indicating more refractory pyridine/pyrrole-type species.
Physicochemical properties of hydrotreated oils:
- Hydrotreatment markedly improved physical properties: dynamic and kinematic viscosities decreased by 1–2 orders of magnitude (e.g., biocrudes 1.3×103–5×103 mm2·s−1 down to 2–14 mm2·s−1 at 400 °C); densities decreased from >1.05 g·cm−3 to ≈0.85 g·cm−3 for high-severity products.
- Water content in oil phases <1 wt% after hydrotreatment; oxygen content (dry basis) <3 % above 360 °C and essentially <0.03 O/C in upgraded products (Van Krevelen).
- Micro carbon residue (µMCR) and TAN decreased substantially; TAN values <1 mg KOH·g−1 at higher severity, improving corrosion outlook for refiners.
- Higher heating values (HHV) of upgraded oils >42 MJ·kg−1; single-feedstock high-temperature products exceeded 44 MJ·kg−1; co-HTL products had slightly lower HHV due to residual nitrogen.
GC–MS and molecular composition:
- Biocrudes: typical lignocellulosic HTL components (phenolics, ketones, small heterocycles). Hydrotreated fractions: broad range of C4–C18 hydrocarbons including n-alkanes, isoalkanes, cycloalkanes, aromatics; oxygenates largely removed in the analyzed volatile/semivolatile range.
- Co-HTL products showed relatively higher aromatic and long-chain hydrocarbon content in heavier fractions and lower saturated fraction abundance across cuts, consistent with resistance of N-containing aromatics to hydrogenation.
Distillation yields and cut characteristics (400 °C hydrotreatment products):
- Distillation cuts (simulated and experimental) showed that increasing hydrotreatment temperature shifts material from bottom residue (BR) to lighter cuts: gasoline and kerosene yields increased, BR decreased sharply with temperature (example: BR reduced from ~54–62 wt% at 340 °C to ~25–37 wt% at 400 °C).
- Average observed BR decrease ≈8.5 ± 1.1 wt% per +20 °C hydrotreating.
- Gasoline yields rose modestly for straw (+3.6 wt%) and more substantially for manure (+13.5 wt%) and co-HTL (+10.7 wt%) as temperature increased.
- Diesel fraction yields changed little with temperature in many cases, suggesting concurrent cracking of diesel-range species.
- Distillate properties: gasoline largely cycloparaffinic (octane numbers estimated ~61–64, below commercial gasoline specs requiring isomerization/reforming); kerosene and diesel fractions contained substantial saturated hydrocarbon content but also aromatics and unsaturated components; sulphur of distillates ranged ~20–110 ppm, above strict fuel specs and indicating a need for additional desulfurization if used in fuels.
Bottom residue behavior and refinery integration:
- BR from single-feedstock hydrotreating was miscible with fossil vacuum gas oil (VGO) at room temperature, enabling straightforward co-processing; BR from co-HTL required elevated temperature (~45 °C) to achieve full miscibility at high BR fractions (75 % BR in VGO), reflecting higher viscosity and refractory components.
- Hydrocracking of BR or co-processing with VGO are viable strategies to further convert heavy fractions to light products.
Process-level carbon efficiency (per 1000 kg C input):
- HTL biocrude yields: straw 410 kg C, manure 440 kg C, co-HTL 531 kg C (co-HTL showed ≈25 % synergy vs non-synergistic expectation).
- End-to-end carbon yield to upgraded oils: straw ≈34 %, manure ≈38 %, co-HTL ≈43 % (co-HTL increases overall carbon recovery to upgraded hydrocarbons despite generating more refractory N-species).
- Co-HTL shifts incremental carbon primarily into diesel and BR fractions rather than gasoline/kerosene; additional hydrocracking or hydrogenation steps would be needed to maximize light fuel carbon yields.
Benefits and practical applications
The study demonstrates that continuous hydrotreatment of HTL biocrudes produced from agricultural wet wastes yields oils with near-crude physical properties and heating values compatible with refinery feedstocks. Key practical implications:
- Co-HTL of manure + straw increases total biocrude yield and overall carbon recovery to upgraded oil compared to single feedstock HTL.
- Upgraded oils can be fractionated to produce gasoline/kerosene/diesel-like cuts suitable for blending or further refinery treatment; heavier fractions are amenable to co-processing with VGO or hydrocracking.
- Residual nitrogen and sulfur in heavier cuts remain the principal refining challenge; mitigation requires additional hydrotreating severity, lower WHSV, or targeted catalytic/process steps (e.g., hydrocracking, staged hydrotreating, sorption/desorption strategies).
Future trends and possibilities
Key avenues for further research and process development:
- Catalyst and reactor optimization to address refractory N-heterocycles: tailored catalysts (higher activity for hydrodenitrogenation), staged processing, lower WHSV, or catalyst geometries that reduce mass-transfer limitations (extrudates vs crushed particles) should be evaluated.
- Integration of hydrocracking or tailored hydrogenation to convert bottom residues to light fuels, including techno-economic assessment of hydrogen demand and catalyst lifetimes.
- Advanced aqueous phase valorization (gasification, wet oxidation, electrochemical approaches) to increase overall carbon and energy recovery from HTL streams.
- Scale-up testing under realistic refinery co-processing conditions and long-duration catalyst stability tests to assess deactivation mechanisms from HTL derived contaminants.
- Life-cycle assessment and supply-chain analyses to quantify greenhouse gas benefits and logistics for farm-scale co-feedstock collection.
Conclusion
The combined HTL (co-liquefaction) of cow manure and wheat straw followed by continuous catalytic hydrotreating (CoMo/NiMo two-stage sulfided catalyst system) and distillation yields upgraded hydrocarbons with properties approaching refinery feedstock specifications and provides higher overall carbon recovery (up to ≈43 % carbon to upgraded oils) than single-feedstock routes. However, co-HTL oils contain more recalcitrant nitrogen-containing aromatics that reduce hydrogen consumption efficiency and require more severe or additional processing to meet stringent fuel nitrogen limits. Bottom residues from single-feedstock routes mix readily with VGO, and the co-HTL BR is miscible at elevated temperature, supporting refinery integration options. Overall, co-HTL with targeted downstream upgrading offers a promising pathway to valorize wet agricultural wastes into advanced biofuels and refinery intermediates.
References
The original article and references as provided by the authors (selected key citations below):
- dos Passos, J.S., Straka, P., Auersvald, M., Biller, P., Upgrading of hydrothermal liquefaction biocrudes from mono- and co-liquefaction of cow manure and wheat straw through hydrotreating and distillation, Chemical Engineering Journal 452 (2023) 139636.
- Elliott, D.C., Historical developments in hydroprocessing bio-oils, Energy & Fuels 21 (2007) 1792–1815.
- Thorson, M.R., et al., Scaleable hydrotreating of HTL biocrude to produce fuel blendstocks, Energy & Fuels 35 (2021) 11346–11352.
- Madsen, R.B., Glasius, M., Biller, P., Characterizing semivolatile organic compounds of biocrude from hydrothermal liquefaction of biomass, Energy & Fuels 31 (2017) 4122–4134.
- Subramaniam, S., et al., Extended catalyst lifetime testing for HTL biocrude hydrotreating to produce fuel blendstocks from wet wastes, ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 9 (2021) 12825–12832.
- Anastasakis, K., Biller, P., Continuous hydrothermal liquefaction of biomass in a novel pilot plant with heat recovery and hydraulic oscillation, Energies 11 (2018) 2695.
- Channiwala, S.A., Parikh, P.P., A unified correlation for estimating HHV of solid, liquid and gaseous fuels, Fuel 81 (2002) 1051–1063.
Full reference list included in the original publication contains extended citations (1–46) covering HTL, hydrotreating, catalyst behavior, analytical methods, and aqueous phase valorization.
Content was automatically generated from an orignal PDF document using AI and may contain inaccuracies.