Efficient One-Stage Bio-Oil Upgrading over Sulfided Catalysts

Scientific articles | 2020 | REFINE LabInstrumentation
FTIR Spectroscopy, GC/MSD, Viscometers, Elemental Analysis
Industries
Energy & Chemicals
Manufacturer
Anton Paar, Metrohm, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Agilent Technologies

Importance of the topic


Upgrading fast-pyrolysis bio-oils into refinery-compatible intermediates is a key route to integrating lignocellulosic biomass into existing fuel value chains. Bio-oils contain high oxygen content, water and reactive species that lower heating value, increase acidity and promote catalyst fouling. Efficient one-stage hydrotreatment that yields stable, deoxygenated liquids suitable for refinery coprocessing could reduce processing complexity and costs compared with multistage systems that rely on noble-metal presaturation zones.

Objectives and study overview


This study evaluated long-term performance (up to 80 h time-on-stream) of several sulfided Ni–Mo catalysts (lab-made and commercial) for one-stage hydrotreatment of an ablative fast-pyrolysis straw bio-oil. Reaction conditions were selected (340 °C, 4 MPa, LHSV 0.5 h−1) to balance deoxygenation and limited aromatic hydrogenation. The goals were to compare catalyst activity and stability, characterize product quality over time, identify deactivation trends, and assess whether mild hydrotreatment products can be fractionated into refinery-relevant cuts.

Methodology and instrumentation


  • Feedstock: organic phase of straw (wheat/barley 50/50 wt%) fast-pyrolysis bio-oil, doped with 0.5 wt% dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) to maintain catalyst sulfidation (total feed S ≈ 0.41 wt% dry basis).
  • Reactor: stainless-steel fixed-bed, cocurrent downflow (length 320 mm, diameter 23 mm); thermowell with multiple thermocouples enabling bed profiling.
  • Catalysts: commercial and lab-made Ni–Mo on Al2O3 or SiO2 supports; lab catalysts prepared by co-impregnation or two-step impregnation variants; textural and compositional characterization by BET, BJH pore analysis, bulk density, ICP-MS (and XRF for one commercial sample).
  • Activation: in situ sulfidation (345 °C, 4 MPa) using hydrotreated gas oil with DMDS; catalyst stabilization via hydrotreatment of straight-run gas oil to track HDS performance.
  • Hydrotreatment conditions: 340 °C, 4 MPa H2, feed 50 g·h−1 (LHSV 0.5 h−1), H2/feed volumetric ratio ≈ 1800:1. One SiO2-based test was run at increased severity (360 °C, 8 MPa) due to poor initial performance.
  • Product handling: liquids collected cumulatively every 4 h, separated into organic and aqueous phases by gravity/centrifugation; gases sampled into Tedlar bags.
  • Analytical methods: elemental analysis (ASTM D5291), GC-MS for detailed organics, FTIR-ATR combined with principal component analysis (PCA) for rapid product fingerprinting and catalyst-health monitoring, SIMDIS/SIMDIST distillation, Faix titration for carbonyls, Carboxylic Acid Number (CAN) titration, BET, N2 adsorption, ICP-MS/XRF for catalyst metals, gas analysis for C1–C5, CO, CO2, H2, light hydrocarbons.

Main results and discussion


  • Catalyst performance: silica-supported NiMo (NiMo/SiO2) performed poorly in both hydrodesulfurization (HDS) and hydrodeoxygenation (HDO) and was terminated early due to low deoxygenation and coking tendencies. Among alumina-supported catalysts, performance differed markedly despite similar nominal loadings—preparation method and Ni/Mo atomic ratio influenced activity and stability.
  • Best catalyst: a lab-made NiMo/Al2O3 prepared by co-impregnation (Exp_4/L) and a commercial NiMo/Al2O3 (Exp_2/C) showed the most stable HDO performance over 80 h. Exp_4/L exhibited the highest initial CAN conversion (~82%) and maintained good product properties (small density and viscosity increases after 80 h, micro Conradson carbon residue <1% for Exp_4/L).
  • Unexpected HDS vs HDO decoupling: the commercial catalyst with the highest HDS activity (Exp_1/C) did not provide the best HDO performance. Thus HDS performance is not a reliable predictor for bio-oil deoxygenation capability.
  • Time-on-stream trends: all catalysts showed gradual loss of HDO capacity with TOS, most significantly in the first ~40 h, manifested as increased O/C and decreased H/C (Van Krevelen), rising organic-phase yield (less water produced), higher density, viscosity, TAN/CAN deterioration and higher micro-CCR. Carbonyl conversion decreased (e.g., from ~92% to ~84% for the better catalysts), and CAN conversion declined with TOS.
  • Coke deposition: carbon content on spent catalysts concentrated near the top of the bed (first ~35 mm), consistent with deposition from the most reactive oxygenates. Coke accumulation correlated with activity loss; catalysts prepared without optimal calcination (drying only) showed higher coke loading.
  • Gaseous products: outlet gases were dominated by H2 (excess feed). C1–C4 product rates and product ratios (CO/CO2, CO/CH4, (CO+CO2)/CH4, C2–C4 alkanes/alkenes) reflected catalyst activity: higher gaseous productivity and higher alkane/alkene ratios correlated with better hydrogenation and overall HDO activity. Silica support gave lower C1–C5 yields and higher alkene fractions (weaker hydrogenation).
  • Rapid monitoring: FTIR-ATR coupled with PCA separated feed vs products and provided a simple metric of product quality and catalyst health; PCA captured >99% spectral variance in two components and tracked deactivation in near real time. Simple solvent flushing partially restored activity for one catalyst.
  • Product quality and energy content: hydrotreatment raised higher heating values from the raw bio-oil to ~38–41 MJ·kg−1 for most good-performing catalysts (roughly doubling bio-oil HHV). Organic-phase yields for alumina catalysts were ~50–60 wt% and decreased in quality with TOS.
  • Hydrocarbon formation: GC-MS showed conversion of oxygenates into hydrocarbons—n-alkanes, cycloalkenes and cycloalkanes and aromatics increased markedly after hydrotreatment. Alumina-support catalysts produced more cycloalkanes (saturated hydrogenation products) than silica-supported ones, indicating stronger hydrogenation on alumina NiMo.
  • Distillation of a representative hydrotreated product (Exp_6/L, 24–32 h TOS) produced fractions resembling refinery cuts: light gasoline (<100 °C), heavy gasoline (100–200 °C), diesel (200–360 °C) and residue (>360 °C). SIMDIS predicted yields well. Light gasoline was mainly hydrocarbons (∼70% of that cut) and low oxygen; heavy gasoline and diesel fractions contained significant phenolics, acids and carbonyls, concentrated differently (acids concentrated in 100–360 °C range; carbonyls mostly in <200 °C). The residue was highly aromatic with lower oxygen content and is a candidate for coprocessing in hydrocracking or vacuum feedstock streams.

Benefits and practical applications


  • Demonstrated feasibility of single-stage sulfided NiMo hydrotreatment (without noble-metal pretreatment) to produce refinery-compatible fractions for co-processing, at least over tens of hours of operation with select catalysts.
  • Identified catalyst preparation and support (Al2O3 and impregnation protocol) as critical levers to maximize HDO performance and long-term stability.
  • Provided an operationally simple, rapid monitoring approach (FTIR-ATR + PCA) for catalyst health and product quality that could be adapted for online process control in pilot or demonstration units.
  • Distillation mapping of product cuts supplies guidance for downstream refinery integration: light naphtha-like cuts may enter gasoline pools directly, whereas heavy gasoline and diesel fractions containing phenolics/acids will need further hydrotreatment, extraction or dedicated coprocessing steps; the aromatic residue is amenable to hydrocracking or catalytic cracking with attention to coke formation.

Future trends and opportunities


  • Optimize Ni/Mo atomic ratios and impregnation procedures for alumina supports to minimize coke formation and maximize sustained HDO activity; mechanistic surface studies could guide formulation.
  • Develop mild two-zone approaches with low-temperature saturation (possibly reduced metal catalysts) combined with sulfided HDO beds, but with focus on economic and operational simplicity relative to prior two-stage setups.
  • Scale-up studies assessing catalyst lifetimes beyond 80 h, sulfur management strategies (feed doping vs other options), and continuous mitigation methods (periodic solvent flushing, staged bed designs) are needed to reach industrially meaningful runtimes.
  • Integration strategies for upgraded fractions—co-processing schemes, extraction/isolation of valuable phenolics for chemicals, and targeted post-hydrotreatment steps for diesel-range fractions—offer value chains beyond direct fuel blending.
  • Real-time spectroscopy + multivariate models (FTIR/PCA or Raman/ML) development for industrial online monitoring and automated control to extend catalyst life and maintain product specs.

Conclusion


One-stage hydrotreatment of straw-derived fast pyrolysis bio-oil over sulfided NiMo catalysts can produce refinery-relevant intermediate streams with substantially increased HHV and reduced oxygen content, but catalyst formulation and preparation critically determine activity and stability. Alumina-supported NiMo catalysts—especially a co-impregnated formulation—provided the best balance of HDO activity and stability over 80 h. HDS metrics alone do not predict HDO performance. Catalyst deactivation via coking and interaction with water/oxygenates remains a central challenge; nevertheless, fractionation of the mildly hydrotreated product yields usable naphtha- and vacuum-type fractions that can be integrated into refinery processing with appropriate downstream treatment. Rapid FTIR-based fingerprinting with PCA offers a practical tool for ongoing process monitoring and control.

References


The summary is based on: Shumeiko B.; Auersvald M.; Straka P.; Simacek P.; Vrtiska D.; Kubicka D. Efficient One-Stage Bio-Oil Upgrading over Sulfided Catalysts. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 2020, 8, 15149–15167. The paper’s references include key works on fast pyrolysis, bio-oil hydrotreatment, catalysts (NiMo, CoMo, noble metals), catalytic deactivation, and distillate analyses cited within the original article.

Content was automatically generated from an orignal PDF document using AI and may contain inaccuracies.

Downloadable PDF for viewing
 

Similar PDF

Quantitative Study of Straw Bio-oil Hydrodeoxygenation over a Sulfided NiMo Catalyst
Hydrotreatment of straw bio-oil from ablative fast pyrolysis to produce suitable refinery intermediates
Upgrading of hydrothermal liquefaction biocrudes from mono- and co-liquefaction of cow manure and wheat straw through hydrotreating and distillation
Bio-based refinery intermediate production via hydrodeoxygenation of fast pyrolysis bio-oil