Importance of the topic
The chemical recycling of waste plastics and tires by pyrolysis yields complex pyrolysis oils that are potential feedstocks for steam crackers, petrochemical production, or upgraded transportation fuels. Accurate assessment of aromatic hydrocarbon content in these oils is critical because aromatics influence processability (coking in steam cracking), fuel properties (heat value, smoke point, cetane number) and regulatory compliance (limits on total and polyaromatic content in aviation and diesel fuels). Standard refinery laboratory methods are commonly used for aromatic quantification, but their suitability for waste-derived pyrolysis oils (characterized by high olefin and heteroatom content) has not been systematically compared until this study.
Objectives and overview of the study
This work compares three refinery-available, standardized methods for aromatic determination across a variety of pyrolysis oils and fractions (naphtha/kerosene/gas oil) from polyolefin plastics and scrap tires, including products after catalytic hydrotreatment. The methods evaluated are: Fluorescence Indicator Adsorption (FIA, ASTM D1319), High-Performance Liquid Chromatography with Refractive Index detection (HPLC-RI, EN 12916 / ASTM D6379/D6591), and comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography with FID detection (GC×GC-FID, ASTM D8396). The study uses model compounds and reference procedures (saturates isolation) to explain discrepancies and to establish which method best represents actual aromatic content in these challenging matrices.
Methodology
- Samples: Pyrolysis oils produced from waste polyethylene films, a mixture of polyethylene and polypropylene containers, and scrap tires. Fractionation by distillation produced naphtha (<150 °C), kerosene (150–250 °C) and gas oil (250–360 °C) cuts. Several oils were hydrotreated at varying severities (up to 360 °C, 10 MPa) with a commercial sulfided catalyst to assess aromatic hydrogenation.
- Model validation: >80 individual model compounds (aromatic variants, dienes, heterocompounds) were analyzed to evaluate method responses and potential interferences. Spiking experiments with representative dienes (e.g., octa-1,7-diene, 2,5-dimethylhexa-2,4-diene, D-limonene, α-terpinene) probed FIA behavior.
- Comparative reference: For deeply hydrotreated gas-oil fractions (minimal olefins/heteroatoms), saturates were isolated by Ag-SiO2 adsorption and weighed; aromatic content was inferred as the remainder and used as an empirical reference for method accuracy.
Instrumentation used
- FIA: Normalab Analysis FIA apparatus following ASTM D1319; silica gel stationary phase, UOP dye indicator gel.
- HPLC-RI: Shimadzu HPLC configured with Agilent Zorbax NH2 and SB-CN columns (in series), n‑heptane mobile phase, differential refractive index detector; calibration standards included o‑xylene (monoaromatics), fluorene or 1‑methylnaphthalene (diaromatics), and phenanthrene (triaromatics) per relevant standards.
- GC×GC-FID: LECO QuadJet SD system built on Agilent 8890 GC with dual-stage modulator, DB‑17 ms primary column and DB‑1 HT secondary column, FID detection; data processed with ChromaTOF and FID area corrected via effective carbon number approach.
- Other: Fischer HMS 500 automatic distillation for fractionation, Ag‑SiO2 columns for saturates isolation, laboratory hydrotreatment unit (CACTU Solutions) for catalytic upgrading.
Main results and discussion
- FIA (ASTM D1319)
- FIA routinely overestimates aromatic content in crude pyrolysis oils, particularly kerosene and naphtha fractions from plastics and tires. The method’s silica-dye displacement visualization cannot reliably distinguish aromatic start/intermediate bands when samples contain abundant dienes and heteroatoms: common pyrolysis dienes (e.g., limonene) generate an indistinct transition and are reported as aromatics.
- Consequently, FIA can misclassify large fractions of olefins and hetero-compounds (sulfur- and nitrogen-containing species) as aromatics, producing gross overestimates (differences up to ~40 percentage points in some kerosene samples compared with GC×GC).
- FIA remains applicable only for low final-boiling, hydrotreated, low-olefin samples where the bands are well resolved; it is also the most time-consuming method.
- HPLC-RI (EN 12916 / ASTM D6379/D6591)
- HPLC-RI yields biased results dependent on the molecular structures present because differential refractive index response factors vary substantially across aromatic sub-classes. Extensive model-compound testing showed that cycloaromatics and aromatic olefins give substantially higher RI responses than the o‑xylene calibration standard while many diaromatic structures (naphthalenes, biphenyls, non-condensed ring diaromatics) respond more weakly than fluorene.
- Consequences: monoaromatics (especially cycloaromatics common in these samples) are overestimated; diaromatics and polyaromatics are often underestimated. The choice of diaromatic calibration standard (fluorene in EN 12916 vs 1‑methylnaphthalene in ASTM methods) significantly influences results; recalculation with 1‑methylnaphthalene brought some samples into closer agreement with GC×GC.
- HPLC-RI is fast and well established for middle distillates, but without compound-class-specific response correction or use of sample-appropriate calibration standards, results may be misleading for pyrolysis oils.
- GC×GC-FID (ASTM D8396)
- GC×GC-FID produced the most reliable and consistent aromatic quantification across sample types. Two-dimensional separation minimizes coelution of non-aromatic interferences, and FID provides a relatively uniform mass-response that can be corrected using effective carbon number to reduce residual bias.
- For deeply hydrotreated gas-oil samples, GC×GC-FID results aligned closely (often within <5% rel.) with the empirical saturates-isolation reference, supporting its accuracy.
- Limitations: in a few low-quality, deeply hydrotreated tire gas oils, some highly condensed cycloalkanes eluted in monoaromatic regions and produced a small positive bias, but this was much smaller than biases observed with HPLC-RI and FIA.
Practical implications and benefits
- Method selection matters: For reliable aromatic quantification in waste-derived pyrolysis oils (particularly pretreated or crude oils rich in olefins and heteroatoms), GC×GC-FID is the preferred method despite longer analysis time and higher complexity.
- HPLC-RI can be used for rapid screening and routine middle-distillate control but requires careful choice of calibration standards and awareness of systematic biases toward specific aromatic subclasses; in many cases the method overestimates monoaromatics and underestimates diaromatics/polyaromatics without correction.
- FIA is not recommended for crude pyrolysis oils or high-olefin tire-derived kerosenes due to diene/heteroatom misclassification; FIA may be acceptable for well-hydrotreated, low-boiling samples.
- Accurate aromatics data are essential for deciding downstream processing: hydrotreating severity, steam cracking suitability, and compliance with fuel specifications (JET-A1 aromatics limits, diesel polyaromatics targets).
Future trends and opportunities
- Broader adoption of advanced detectors: GC‑VUV (ASTM D8519) offers structural discrimination and promising performance but is costly; continued inter-laboratory validation and cost reduction could increase uptake.
- Method integration: Combining GC×GC-FID (quantitation) with GC×GC‑TOF/MS or GC‑VUV (structural confirmation) will improve compound-class identification and correction of quantitation biases.
- Standard updates: HPLC-RI calibration protocols should be revised to include multiple or sample-specific standards (e.g., 1‑methylnaphthalene for diaromatics) and response-factor libraries to reduce bias across pyrolysis-derived matrices.
- Automation, chemometrics and AI: Data-driven deconvolution of complex GC×GC datasets and machine-learning correction models could accelerate analysis and improve robustness for routine QA/QC.
- Industry application: Implementation of GC×GC‑based workflows in refineries processing pyrolysis oils will enable better control of hydrotreatment steps and safer integration as steam cracker feedstocks.
Conclusions
- This comparative evaluation demonstrates that GC×GC-FID (ASTM D8396) provides the most accurate and robust aromatic quantification for pyrolysis oils from waste plastics and tires, closely matching independent saturates-based reference data.
- HPLC-RI is fast but prone to compositional bias due to variable RI responses across aromatic subclasses and the choice of calibration standards; careful calibration and awareness of these biases are essential when using HPLC-RI with WPPO matrices.
- FIA (ASTM D1319) is the least reliable for crude pyrolysis oils because dienes and hetero-compounds are frequently misidentified as aromatics; FIA may be limited to well-hydrotreated, low-boiling samples.
- For process monitoring, regulatory compliance (fuel aromatics limits) and feedstock selection, GC×GC-FID is recommended as the reference method within refinery laboratories, while acknowledging its higher complexity and cost.
References
- Dogu O, Pelucchi M, Van de Vijver R, Van Steenberge PHM, D’Hooge DR, Cuoci A, et al. The chemistry of chemical recycling of solid plastic waste via pyrolysis and gasification: State-of-the-art, challenges, and future directions. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science 2021;84:100901.
- Kusenberg M, Eschenbacher A, Delva L, De Meester S, Delikonstantis E, Stefanidis GD, et al. Towards high-quality petrochemical feedstocks from mixed plastic packaging waste via advanced recycling: The past, present and future. Fuel Processing Technology 2022;238:107474.
- Quek A, Balasubramanian R. Liquefaction of waste tires by pyrolysis for oil and chemicals—A review. Journal of Analytical and Applied Pyrolysis 2013;101:1–16.
- ASTM D1319-20. Standard Test Method for Hydrocarbon Types in Liquid Petroleum Products by Fluorescent Indicator Adsorption. ASTM International; 2020.
- EN 12916:2019. Petroleum products — Determination of aromatic hydrocarbon types in middle distillates — HPLC method with refractive index detection. CEN; 2019.
- ASTM D8396-22. Standard Test Method for Hydrocarbon-Type Analysis of Middle Distillates Using Comprehensive Two-Dimensional Gas Chromatography with Flame Ionization Detection. ASTM International; 2022.
- ASTM D8519-23. Standard Test Method for Determination of Hydrocarbon Types in Waste Plastic Process Oil Using GC-VUV. ASTM International; 2023.
- Striebich RC, Shafer LM, Adams RK, West ZJ, DeWitt MJ, Zabarnick S. Hydrocarbon group-type analysis of petroleum-derived and synthetic fuels using two-dimensional gas chromatography. Energy & Fuels 2014;28(9):5696–706.
- Gonzalez L, Bramer J, Rymill A, Wrzesinski P, Edwards T, Metz A, et al. Evaluation of Alternative Methods to Measure Aromatic Content of Aviation Fuels. 2020. (Interlaboratory/method comparison report).
- Straka P, Auersvald M, Vrtiška D, Kittel H, Šimáček P, Vozka P. Production of transportation fuels via hydrotreating of scrap tires pyrolysis oil. Chemical Engineering Journal 2023;460:141764.
Content was automatically generated from an orignal PDF document using AI and may contain inaccuracies.